Variability of histologic lesions in relation to biopsy site in gluten-sensitive enteropathy.Am J Gastroenterol. 2005 Jan;100(1):177-85.

OBJECTIVES: It is generally believed that in gluten-sensitive enteropathy or celiac disease (CD), mucosal lesions may have a patchy distribution. We wanted to verify this concept and establish whether one or more biopsy samples are needed in order to make a correct diagnosis of CD. METHODS: One hundred and twelve consecutive children with positive antiendomysium (EMA) or antitissue transglutaminase (tTGA) antibodies, referred to us for suspected CD, were enrolled in a prospective fashion. During upper GI endoscopy four to five biopsies were taken from Treitz and/or distal duodenum (D3), intermediate duodenum (D2), proximal duodenum (D1), and duodenal bulb (B). Histologic lesions were classified according to Marsh criteria modified by Oberhuber. RESULTS: A total of 110 patients, all HLA-DQ2 or DQ8 positive, had a final diagnosis of CD (59 classic, 28 atypical, and 23 silent): 102/110 (92.7%) had type 3 lesion-(a) mild, (b) moderate, or (c) severe-in at least one site and 94/110 (85.4%) had villous atrophy (VA) of some degree in all sites. VA of identical degree was present in all biopsy sites in 55/110 (50%) patients. Total VA (type 3c) was present in at least one site in 85/110 (75%), in all sites in 50/110 (45.4%), and significantly increased in aborad direction ((chi(2) > 26.22 with (= 0.01 and d.f. (degrees of freedom) = 12). Eight out of 110 (7.2%) CD patients had exclusively type 1 or 2 lesions, no patient had lesion variability >1 degree and none had normal biopsies. There was no correlation between type or distribution of histologic lesions and clinical presentation of CD. CONCLUSIONS: Mucosal atrophy is present in 85% of patients with CD and total VA is significantly more frequent in distal duodenum or proximal jejunum. Fifty percent of patients have identical VA throughout the duodenum and no duodenal areas are histologically normal. In genetically susceptible children with positive serology, a diagnosis of CD can reliably be made even if biopsies are not taken from the distal duodenum or jejunum.

Duodenal versus jejunal biopsies in suspected celiac disease.Endoscopy. 2004 Nov;36(11):993-6.

BACKGROUND AND STUDY AIMS: In the past, small-bowel biopsies for diagnosis of celiac disease were taken from the jejunum with a suction capsule, but nowadays most physicians take endoscopic biopsies from the distal duodenum. To validate that practice we compared the diagnostic yield of endoscopic duodenal biopsies with that of endoscopic jejunal biopsies. In addition, we describe a method of orienting biopsy specimens optimally. PATIENTS AND METHODS: Upper endoscopy was performed with a colonoscope. Four jejunal and four duodenal biopsies were taken and oriented immediately thereafter. The pathologist rated the orientation as poor, adequate, or good, and histopathological results were expressed according to the Marsh classification. Jejunal and duodenal biopsy results were compared. RESULTS: 146 patients were included. Jejunal biopsies were taken in 142 patients, and Marsh I-II lesions were found in 56 and Marsh III lesions in 15 patients. In three patients duodenal biopsies were normal while jejunal biopsies showed Marsh I-II lesions. No discrepancies were found in patients with Marsh III lesions. Orientation was good in all biopsies. CONCLUSION: Duodenal biopsies are sufficient to diagnose full-blown celiac disease (Marsh III), but Marsh I-II lesions may be missed in some cases.